Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

About Louis Critelli

Louis Critelli Colts Neck, NJ Real Estate Agent Headshot

Agent Details

Meet Louis

Broker | Owner
Currently, the Broker of Record / Owner of Critelli REALTORS®, a Luxury Real Estate company, Louis has made New Jersey his home for over 60 years. A former resident and graduate of Holmdel High School, he has been specializing in the marketing of New Jersey's Finest Homes for over 33 Years. Louis' education includes 2 Bachelor's Degrees from Villanova University and an MBA in Finance and Accounting from Rutgers.
 
With decades of expertise and deep-rooted local knowledge, Critelli REALTORS® is dedicated to delivering an unparalleled luxury real estate experience. By combining cutting-edge technology with a client-first approach, we elevate the marketing and sales of homes while ensuring a seamless, high-touch service experience that exceeds expectations.
 
Before opening Critelli REALTORS® in 2005, Louis was the recipient of the NJAR "Distinguished Service Award" a Lifetime Membership award given to approx 1% of NAR Members in NJ. Other awards in his career include being named as the top agent for Coldwell Banker in Monmouth & Ocean Counties for 2001 through 2005, as well as the number 9 Agent (for Coldwell Banker in the Greater New York, New Jersey Area) for 2003, out of 3500 agents. He was also the recipient of the Coldwell Banker Presidents Premier Award, as well as Coldwell Banker's President Elite Award for 1998-2005.
 
These awards placed him in the top 1 percent of over 120,000 agents nationwide. This award was received as a result of his thorough knowledge of the real estate market, extensive expertise, unparalleled work ethic, and relationship to his fellow brokers. Louis is currently considered one of the area's top agents and was awarded the "Circle of Excellence Platinum Award" ( received by less than 1% of all agents ) Gold, Silver, and Bronze Awards. He was elected as the Chairman of the Arbitration Committee and has served on the Professional Standards Committee, Grievance Committee, Chairman of the Budget and Finance Committee, Managers Committee, and Public Relations committee for the Monmouth County Board of REALTORS® for multiple years.

Testimonials

Jobin J.

Jobin J.

I had the pleasure of working with Lou Critelli on my first home purchase and I can't recommend him enough! My wife and I have been looking for homes on and off for about 2 years and worked with multiple real estate agents. Nig...
Read More
Max S.

Max S.

Louis was very professional and knowledgeable of the market specifics that made our listing with him such a success. He handled our listing with great care even though it was a smaller listing for him, and negotiated an excelle...
Read More
Kim M.

Kim M.

Louis has done a great job for me selling my old house and purchasing a new one. He's a great negotiator and is always on top of his game. Hiring Louis was the best thing for me.
Read More
Eric & Lisa G.

Eric & Lisa G.

In an extremely complex and difficult short sale of our home, Lou Critelli and his staff worked diligently and tirelessly to get the deal done. Special kudos go out to Cathy, from his office, who kept us abreast of every "T" th...
Read More
Seller

Seller

Six times my house was on the market, Lou walked in and told me this is what you need to do if you really want to sell. I Did everything he said, listed it, and sold it in 2 weeks. The man is the best out there.
Read More
Matt S.

Matt S.

Lou’s approach was very thoughtful, helpful, and strategic. His creative ideas resulted in an increase in net proceeds received from the sale.
Read More
Steven K.

Steven K.

My wife and I recently purchased our first home. During the house hunting process, we visited (interviewed) with a number of agents and Louis Critelli was head and shoulders above the others making it an easy decision to go wit...
Read More
Terry & Jan C.

Terry & Jan C.

Louis is a pleasure to deal with. He is great in his professional demeanor, is patient, never pressured us to drop our price, and always shares a realistic market perspective. As our neighbor, he was knowledgeable in sharing th...
Read More
Alyssa S.

Alyssa S.

If you’re looking for a top-notch realtor who truly cares, look no further than Louis Critelli! Not only is he an expert in the local real estate market, but he’s also a genuinely great person. Louis goes above and beyond for h...
Read More

Find Your Next Dream Home

Browse Homes

Work With Us

Experience seamless service and expert guidance in the New Jersey luxury real estate market. Contact us today to start your journey.

Follow Me on Instagram